Facing an economic slowdown: Counties with the fastest shrinking local economies in the US
The United States is in a period of historic, continuous economic growth, with GDP climbing every quarter since mid-2009. While this trend is good news for most Americans, not all parts of the country have experienced the same growth. In fact, in nearly every state, there is at least one county where GDP has contracted in recent years.
Using data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, 24/7 Wall St. reviewed GDP change from 2013 through 2018 at the county and county equivalent level to identify the fastest shrinking local economy in every state.
California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire are the only states where no counties reported a decline in GDP between 2013 and 2018. Still, each of these states has at least one county where economic growth over that period lagged behind the comparable 13% national GDP growth. Perhaps not surprisingly, overall economic growth has been faster in these four states than in most other states over the last five years.
Coronavirus: Can the Fed save the economy, and your 401k? It doesn't look like it.
Economic slowdown: This could spell trouble for the rising number of people behind on car payments
In 13 counties on this list, mining, quarrying, and oil extraction – a particularly volatile industry – reported the largest decline in economic output of any other industry. Many of these counties are located in states that rank among the top coal producers, including Pennsylvania and West Virginia – and between 2013 and 2018, total U.S. coal production has fallen by over 23%.
Slow or negative GDP growth are not the only indicators of poor economic conditions in many of the counties on this list. In most of these counties, the annual unemployment rate is higher than the comparable 3.9% national rate. Additionally, In the vast majority of counties on this list, the typical household earns less than the median income across the state as a whole.
Such conditions may be pushing people out of these areas and contributing to population decline – the vast majority of counties on this list are home to fewer people today than they were five years ago.
1. Alabama: Lawrence County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -29.5% (county) +5.5% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $563.2 million (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Manufacturing (-75.2% GDP change)
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -4.1 ppt. (8.3% to 4.2%)
• Median household income: $44,515 (county) $48,486 (state)
• Largest place in county: Moulton
2. Alaska: Yakutat City and Borough
• GDP change 2013-2018: -33.9% (county) -3% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $28.4 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Educational services
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -1.3 ppt. (9.5% to 8.2%)
• Median household income: $65,833 (county) $76,715 (state)
• Largest place in county: Yakutat
Can't find hand sanitizers?:Here's how to make it at home with vodka or rubbing alcohol
3. Arizona: Gila County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -7.9% (county) +15.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $2 billion (0.6% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Finance and insurance
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.7 ppt. (9.6% to 5.9%)
• Median household income: $42,092 (county) $56,213 (state)
• Largest place in county: Payson
4. Arkansas: Lee County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -31.5% (county) +4.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $178.1 million (0.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -4.5 ppt. (9.3% to 4.8%)
• Median household income: $28,367 (county) $45,726 (state)
• Largest place in county: Marianna
5. California: Colusa County
• GDP change 2013-2018: +5.3% (county) +22.5% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $1.7 billion (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Administrative and support and waste management and remediation services
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -6 ppt. (18.9% to 12.9%)
• Median household income: $56,704 (county) $71,228 (state)
• Largest place in county: Colusa
6. Colorado: Kiowa County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -25.4% (county) +20.7% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $73.8 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.7 ppt. (4.5% to 1.8%)
• Median household income: $39,784 (county) $68,811 (state)
• Largest place in county: Eads
Can't save?: 9 savings strategies to boost your finances
7. Connecticut: Litchfield County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -3.6% (county) +1.6% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $7.7 billion (3.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Arts, entertainment, and recreation
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.3 ppt. (7.1% to 3.8%)
• Median household income: $78,314 (county) $76,106 (state)
• Largest place in county: Torrington
8. Delaware: New Castle County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -0.7% (county) +6.1% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $42.5 billion (67.7% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Information
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.8 ppt. (6.5% to 3.7%)
• Median household income: $70,996 (county) $65,627 (state)
• Largest place in county: Wilmington
9. Florida: Union County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -4.7% (county) +18% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $299.2 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.9 ppt. (6.3% to 3.4%)
• Median household income: $41,770 (county) $53,267 (state)
• Largest place in county: Lake Butler
10. Georgia: Putnam County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -25.5% (county) +17.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $445.7 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.3 ppt. (10.3% to 5%)
• Median household income: $51,245 (county) $55,679 (state)
• Largest place in county: Eatonton
11. Hawaii: Honolulu County
• GDP change 2013-2018: +9.2% (county) +11.3% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $61.1 billion (73.9% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.1 ppt. (4.4% to 2.3%)
• Median household income: $82,906 (county) $78,084 (state)
• Largest place in county: Honolulu
12. Idaho: Custer County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -40.3% (county) +17.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $177.3 million (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -4.4 ppt. (8.4% to 4%)
• Median household income: $39,957 (county) $53,089 (state)
• Largest place in county: Challis
13. Illinois: Saline County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -26.6% (county) +6.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $849.8 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -4.1 ppt. (10.6% to 6.5%)
• Median household income: $41,167 (county) $63,575 (state)
• Largest place in county: Harrisburg
14. Indiana: Pike County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -25.4% (county) +8.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $690.5 million (0.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.3 ppt. (6.8% to 3.5%)
• Median household income: $52,527 (county) $54,325 (state)
• Largest place in county: Petersburg
15. Iowa: Fremont County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -30% (county) +9.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $241.3 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.3 ppt. (4.2% to 1.9%)
• Median household income: $54,281 (county) $58,580 (state)
• Largest place in county: Hamburg
16. Kansas: Sheridan County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -30.3% (county) +10% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $131.9 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -0.4 ppt. (2.7% to 2.3%)
• Median household income: $56,071 (county) $57,422 (state)
• Largest place in county: Hoxie
17. Kentucky: Union County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -37.3% (county) +4.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $593.5 million (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.7 ppt. (7.7% to 5%)
• Median household income: $42,844 (county) $48,392 (state)
• Largest place in county: Morganfield
Coronavirus concerns: People working out at home to avoid contact at the gym
18. Louisiana: St. John the Baptist Parish
• GDP change 2013-2018: -38.8% (county) +4.7% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $2.4 billion (1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Transportation and warehousing
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3 ppt. (8.7% to 5.7%)
• Median household income: $54,821 (county) $47,942 (state)
• Largest place in county: Laplace
19. Maine: Franklin County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -3% (county) +9.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $985 million (1.7% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Manufacturing
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.7 ppt. (7.7% to 4%)
• Median household income: $48,053 (county) $55,425 (state)
• Largest place in county: Farmington
20. Maryland: Kent County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -1.9% (county) +10.1% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $831.8 million (0.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.9 ppt. (7.2% to 4.3%)
• Median household income: $56,009 (county) $81,868 (state)
• Largest place in county: Chestertown
21. Massachusetts: Berkshire County
• GDP change 2013-2018: +5.8% (county) +13.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $6.7 billion (1.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.4 ppt. (7.4% to 4%)
• Median household income: $56,674 (county) $77,378 (state)
• Largest place in county: Pittsfield
22. Michigan: Baraga County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -4.9% (county) +10.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $259.1 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Wholesale trade
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -8.4 ppt. (14.5% to 6.1%)
• Median household income: $42,444 (county) $54,938 (state)
• Largest place in county: Baraga
23. Minnesota: Cook County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -20.5% (county) +11.1% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $252 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.3 ppt. (5.8% to 3.5%)
• Median household income: $52,271 (county) $68,411 (state)
• Largest place in county: Grand Marais
24. Mississippi: Tallahatchie County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -31.5% (county) +3.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $224.6 million (0.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.8 ppt. (11.1% to 5.3%)
• Median household income: $30,028 (county) $43,567 (state)
• Largest place in county: Charleston
25. Missouri: Pemiscot County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -29.8% (county) +4.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $423.6 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -4.8 ppt. (10.3% to 5.5%)
• Median household income: $33,390 (county) $53,560 (state)
• Largest place in county: Caruthersville
26. Montana: Petroleum County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -39.2% (county) +8.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $22.5 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -0.6 ppt. (4.8% to 4.2%)
• Median household income: $44,688 (county) $52,559 (state)
• Largest place in county: Winnett
Life hacks: 9 ways to 'life hack' your way to larger Social Security benefits
27. Nebraska: Hayes County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -36.9% (county) +8.7% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $41.3 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -1.2 ppt. (3.4% to 2.2%)
• Median household income: $45,515 (county) $59,116 (state)
• Largest place in county: Hayes Center
28. Nevada: Humboldt County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -17.8% (county) +16.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $1.2 billion (0.8% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Construction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.8 ppt. (6.2% to 3.4%)
• Median household income: $70,373 (county) $57,598 (state)
• Largest place in county: Winnemucca
29. New Hampshire: Coos County
• GDP change 2013-2018: +0.4% (county) +10.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $1.1 billion (1.5% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Finance and insurance
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.9 ppt. (6.1% to 3.2%)
• Median household income: $45,696 (county) $74,057 (state)
• Largest place in county: Berlin
30. New Jersey: Salem County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -12.5% (county) +6.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $5 billion (0.9% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Administrative and support and waste management and remediation services
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5 ppt. (10.4% to 5.4%)
• Median household income: $64,309 (county) $79,363 (state)
• Largest place in county: Pennsville
31. New Mexico: Mora County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -42.7% (county) +8.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $76.6 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Transportation and warehousing
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.6 ppt. (11.7% to 6.1%)
• Median household income: $26,968 (county) $48,059 (state)
• Largest place in county: Wagon Mound
Cleaning tips: Your smartphone is 7 times dirtier than your toilet. Here's how to clean it.
32. New York: Jefferson County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -8.1% (county) +8.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $5.9 billion (0.4% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Government and government enterprises
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.6 ppt. (9.2% to 5.6%)
• Median household income: $52,268 (county) $65,323 (state)
• Largest place in county: Watertown
33. North Carolina: Tyrrell County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -22.2% (county) +11.7% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $105.3 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -6.6 ppt. (12.9% to 6.3%)
• Median household income: $35,472 (county) $52,413 (state)
• Largest place in county: Columbia
34. North Dakota: Slope County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -48.6% (county) +0.7% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $57.3 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Manufacturing
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: +0.2 ppt. (2.1% to 2.3%)
• Median household income: $63,942 (county) $63,473 (state)
• Largest place in county: Marmarth
35. Ohio: Adams County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -44.1% (county) +9.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $835.3 million (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.6 ppt. (12.7% to 7.1%)
• Median household income: $36,894 (county) $54,533 (state)
• Largest place in county: West Union
36. Oklahoma: Harmon County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -37.4% (county) +10.7% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $70.3 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -1.4 ppt. (4.3% to 2.9%)
• Median household income: $41,607 (county) $51,424 (state)
• Largest place in county: Hollis
37. Oregon: Sherman County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -13.7% (county) +23.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $583.9 million (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.2 ppt. (9.3% to 4.1%)
• Median household income: $48,056 (county) $59,393 (state)
• Largest place in county: Wasco
38. Pennsylvania: Indiana County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -11.4% (county) +9.3% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $3.9 billion (0.5% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2.8 ppt. (7.7% to 4.9%)
• Median household income: $46,877 (county) $59,445 (state)
• Largest place in county: Indiana
39. Rhode Island: Kent County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -0.5% (county) +3% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $8.1 billion (15.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Finance and insurance
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5 ppt. (8.7% to 3.7%)
• Median household income: $70,223 (county) $63,296 (state)
• Largest place in county: Warwick
40. South Carolina: Clarendon County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -7.2% (county) +15.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $551.3 million (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.6 ppt. (10.3% to 4.7%)
• Median household income: $37,525 (county) $51,015 (state)
• Largest place in county: Manning
41. South Dakota: Potter County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -50.3% (county) +6.6% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $137.6 million (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -0.3 ppt. (3.8% to 3.5%)
• Median household income: $53,600 (county) $56,499 (state)
• Largest place in county: Gettysburg
42. Tennessee: Unicoi County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -13.1% (county) +12.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $494.8 million (0.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Construction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.6 ppt. (10.5% to 4.9%)
• Median household income: $39,851 (county) $50,972 (state)
• Largest place in county: Erwin
Are political texts flooding your phone?: Here's why and how to stop them
43. Texas: Wheeler County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -43.6% (county) +16.3% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $1.1 billion (0.1% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Utilities
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -1.1 ppt. (4.3% to 3.2%)
• Median household income: $49,352 (county) $59,570 (state)
• Largest place in county: Shamrock
44. Utah: Millard County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -8.4% (county) +20.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $773.8 million (0.5% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -0.8 ppt. (4.1% to 3.3%)
• Median household income: $60,445 (county) $68,374 (state)
• Largest place in county: Delta
45. Vermont: Caledonia County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -1.7% (county) +4.4% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $1 billion (3.4% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -2 ppt. (5.3% to 3.3%)
• Median household income: $49,348 (county) $60,076 (state)
• Largest place in county: St. Johnsbury
46. Virginia: Halifax County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -13.2% (county) +6.8% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $1.3 billion (0.3% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Educational services
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5 ppt. (9.1% to 4.1%)
• Median household income: $42,289 (county) $71,564 (state)
• Largest place in county: South Boston
47. Washington: Ferry County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -1.8% (county) +24.5% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $193.3 million (0% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -1.8 ppt. (13.5% to 11.7%)
• Median household income: $41,924 (county) $70,116 (state)
• Largest place in county: Republic
48. West Virginia: Boone County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -46.2% (county) +1.9% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $663.2 million (0.9% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -3.5 ppt. (9.6% to 6.1%)
• Median household income: $38,642 (county) $44,921 (state)
• Largest place in county: Madison
49. Wisconsin: Waushara County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -5.9% (county) +9.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $560.2 million (0.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -5.1 ppt. (8.6% to 3.5%)
• Median household income: $51,195 (county) $59,209 (state)
• Largest place in county: Redgranite
50. Wyoming: Johnson County
• GDP change 2013-2018: -19.2% (county) -1.2% (state)
• 2018 county GDP: $439 million (1.2% of state GDP)
• Fastest shrinking industry: Construction
• Unemployment change 2013-2018: -1.1 ppt. (5.1% to 4%)
• Median household income: $55,991 (county) $62,268 (state)
• Largest place in county: Buffalo
Methodology
To determine the fastest shrinking local economy in every state, 24/7 Wall St. calculated the change in real GDP from 2013 to 2018 for every U.S. county or county equivalent with data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. GDP figures are chained to 2012 dollars. All data on industry level GDP also came from the BEA.
Average annual unemployment rates for 2018 and 2013 came from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Data on population and median household income are five year estimates for 2018 and are from the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey. Largest place in the county is based on population ACS population estimates and places can include cities, towns, villages, and Census designated places.
Independent cities in Virginia were excluded from analysis.
24/7 Wall Street is a Paste BN content partner offering financial news and commentary. Its content is produced independently of Paste BN.