What is a monopoly? Why the Justice Department sued Apple, ruled against Google
The Justice Department is cracking down on alleged monopolies in the tech space.
Google lost a major antitrust case this week after a federal judge ruled Google illegally monopolized online search and abused its dominance in the search market.
And in March, it sued Apple Inc., alleging it restricted developers of apps, products and services used on the iPhone, allowing Apple to extract more money from consumers, software developers publishers and merchants.
What is a monopoly?
A monopoly happens when a business dominates an industry or sector and can therefore control price changes and create entry barriers for competitors.
It’s often used as shorthand in the eyes of the court – rather than looking out for a total monopoly, the Federal Trade Commission defines a monopolist as “a firm with significant and durable market power.”
Another monopoly: What the Google ruling means for your searching
In Apple's case, the lawsuit alleges that the company restricted developers of apps, services and products that could have lowered costs for consumers, according to the legal filing, among other allegations.
“As a result, iPhone users perceive rival smartphones as being lower quality because the experience of messaging friends and family who do not own iPhones is worse − even though Apple is the one responsible for breaking cross-platform messaging,” Garland said.
In a statement, Apple said the lawsuit threatens the company's ability to provide innovative technology and could set a "dangerous precedent."
Why are monopolies bad for the economy?
Without competition, monopolies can keep prices consistent and reliable for customers, Investopedia says. But they can also abuse this advantage by creating low-quality products and faux scarcities. They also don’t encourage companies to compete with innovation.
But not all monopolies are bad for the economy. The United States Postal Service is an example of a government-sanctioned monopoly. The government also regulates public utilities, like gas and electricity, to guarantee a regular supply.
There are a few different types of monopolistic market structures we see in the U.S., according to Investopedia:
- Pure monopoly: Single seller in a market with high barriers to entry, often has a product with no substitutes
- Monopolistic competition: Multiple sellers in an industry operate independently to produce a similar but differentiated product, like hair salons or retail stores
- Natural monopoly: Relies on unique raw materials, technology, research or patent, like a pharmaceutical company
- Public monopoly: Provide essential goods and services but are regulated by government municipalities, like utility companies
DOJ lawsuit: Latest updates on Apple monopoly case
Just Curious for more? We've got you covered.
Paste BN is exploring the questions you and others ask every day. From "Who owns Apple?" to "What is inflation?" to "How much can my landlord raise my rent?" – we're striving to find answers to the most common questions you ask every day. Head to our Just Curious section to see what else we can answer for you.
Contributing: Bart Jansen