Heat waves in the US kill more people in their homes than anywhere else

Show Caption

In July 1999, during Cincinnati’s worst heat wave in recent history, paramedics rushed a man to the hospital after a neighbor found him unresponsive in an attic apartment that had no air conditioning.

It was too late. Doctors declared him dead at the hospital, with a body temperature of 108 degrees. The coroner attributed the cause of death to a brain injury caused by heatstroke.

The Cincinnati man died where most people do during heat waves: his own home.

In the quarter century since his death, thousands more across the United States have suffered similar fates during heat waves like the one now smothering Greater Cincinnati and most of the eastern half of the nation. These are preventable deaths, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, yet they continue to happen because those most at risk often are unable to get the help they need.

An Enquirer analysis of National Weather Service data found that almost half the 3,142 people who died from heat-related ailments in the past 20 years died at home. Like the man from Cincinnati, many people who die in heat waves lack air conditioning or have health problems that can turn deadly in extreme heat.

“When the weather gets this extreme, there's a definite risk,” said Tasha Turner-Bicknell, a nurse and associate professor at the University of Cincinnati College of Nursing.

With Hamilton County under excessive heat watch this week, here’s what the numbers tell us about heat-related deaths in the U.S. – and who’s most susceptible to them.  

Most people die of heat inside homes but deaths at outside locations have surged

Unhoused people are especially vulnerable to heat-related deaths, due to their health issues and limited access to cooling centers. And in the past few years, The Enquirer's analysis found, there has been a surge overall in the number of people dying outdoors during heat waves.

But over the past two decades, The Enquirer found, 45% of people who died at a known location died in their homes, making it the most common location for heat-related deaths.

Outside locations, such as a camp ground or a ball field, were the second most common, making up 41% of deaths. Deaths in cars or other vehicles were next, at 12%, and mobile homes were 2.5%. 

Why do people die so often in their own homes? Lack of air conditioning is a factor, said Turner-Bicknell.

“Most of us take for granted that we live and work in air-conditioned environments,” she said. "But we have a lot of members of our community that do not have air conditioning.” 

In an effort to decrease the number of heat-related deaths and injuries during the summer, the Ohio Department of Development provides eligible low-income families with financial assistance to help pay for air conditioners or to cover their utility bills through its Summer Crisis Program. Last year, the department assisted more than 36,000 Ohio households, according to the website.

In Northern Kentucky, St. Vincent de Paul gives free air conditioners to residents with medical conditions or fans to those who need them. Residents can call the charity's help line at 859-341-3219 Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. to get details.

The need is great. An Enquirer analysis of U.S. Census data found that Cincinnati's most vulnerable residents live in neighborhoods where poverty, a lack of air conditioning, crowded living conditions and an abundance of heat-amplifying glass and concrete all contribute to illness and deaths.

Social isolation may also play a role in heat-related deaths because those living alone may not have anyone checking on them. A study in Rome found a program aimed at decreasing social isolation among people over age 80 was linked to a lower number of deaths during the summer.  

Social isolation can be especially dangerous for those with disabilities or mobility-restrictions, according to Turner-Bicknell, who rely on others to leave their homes.

“Maybe they use a walker or a cane or a wheelchair, and maybe their caregivers are not available," she said. "They might be unable to get out of their house without assistance.”

In 1999, 8 of Cincinnati’s heat wave victims had mental illness

In 1999, Cincinnati’s worst heat wave in recent history resulted in the deaths of 18 residents.   

A least eight residents had a mental illness and may not have been taking their medications at the time of their deaths, while three lived in long-term care facilities.  

According to the CDC, hotter temperatures raise the risk of heat exhaustion, dehydration, and breathing problems, and those with disabilities and chronic health conditions are especially vulnerable.

Other risk factors for heat-related death or injury include being low-income, being under 5 or over 65 years old.  

Heat death rates also vary by race: non-Hispanic Native Americans had the highest rate of heat-related deaths in the country, followed by non-Hispanic Black Americans.

Though scientists say most heat-related deaths are preventable, they also caution that the true impact of heat on Americans' health may be underestimated. They say that's because other causes of death, such as cardiac arrest and stroke, often are not attributed to heat unless it obviously was a factor, as it was in the case of the man from Cincinnati who died in 1999.

The CDC, for example, estimates the number of heat-related deaths over the past 20 years was over 10,500, more than three times higher than the National Weather Service estimates. And some scientists put the number much higher than that.