Is Nick Saban's dynasty in peril? Depends if you ask Lane Kiffin or Paul Finebaum | Opinion
Find someone who loves you the way Lane Kiffin loves cozying up to Nick Saban.
Kiffin is forever grateful to Saban for how Alabama’s coach took in Kiffin when his career was at its lowest. After Southern Cal fired Kiffin, Saban hired him to be his offensive coordinator.
It wasn’t a charity act. Saban needed someone to modernize Alabama’s offense. Kiffin delivered, and, in the process, he rebooted his career.
Kiffin spares no opportunity to praise or defend his former boss. A couple of weeks ago, Kiffin dunked on Jimbo Fisher after Ole Miss beat Fisher’s Aggies, 31-28.
Fisher had called Kiffin "a clown act" in the offseason, and the Aggies coach later hosted a scorched-earth news conference in May in which he dubbed Saban a despicable narcissist and a false god, in response to Saban accusing A&M of buying every player on its roster.
Fisher's offseason comments didn't sit well with Kiffin, whose zingers put Fisher in his place. But making fun of Fisher is easy pickings these days.
MORE: These 13 teams are still alive for College Football Playoff. What's their path to get there?
MORE: Which college football contenders can clinch conference championship spots in Week 11?
STAY UP-TO-DATE: Subscribe to our Sports newsletter now!
Kiffin upped the ante this week when he took on talk-show host Paul Finebaum of the SEC Network, the "Mouth of the South."
Finebaum recently dubbed Saban’s dynasty an endangered species.
"The window on the Saban dynasty is closing," Finebaum said on ESPN after Alabama’s 32-31 overtime loss to LSU.
Finebaum later said "college football has caught up to Alabama."
Kiffin isn’t buying it.
While saying he understands Finebaum's role as a pot-stirrer, Kiffin refuted the notion that Saban's dynasty is waffling.
"It's ridiculous," said Kiffin, whose No. 11 Rebels (8-1) will host No. 9 Alabama (7-2) on Saturday.
As Kiffin correctly put it, Alabama is two plays away from being undefeated. If Will Reichard makes his 50-yard field goal in the closing seconds against Tennessee, Alabama wins that game. If Alabama stops LSU’s two-point conversion, it wins that game.
However, Alabama is not playing like a well-coached team. Alabama is frequently penalized, and special teams gaffes have piled up. Coverage busts and tackling woes flare up, too.
If not for stars like quarterback Bryce Young and linebacker Will Anderson, Alabama may have more than two losses.
For the second straight year, Georgia’s Kirby Smart assembled the most talented roster, not Saban.
So, is Saban’s dynasty in peril, or is this simply a hiccup?
TOPPMEYER:Nick Saban wanted 'parity,' and Lane Kiffin and Brian Kelly helped supply it
OPINION: Auburn football is a trap job? Wrong attitude. Nick Saban is slipping, you know? | Toppmeyer
PLAYOFF ANALYSIS:LSU football can play its way in to CFP, but Tennessee Vols' path is easier
That depends on your definition of dynasty.
To Kiffin’s point, Alabama remains a super-talent compared to much of its competition, and it is a couple of plays away from an undefeated record. Alabama continues to sign top recruits.
However, the way Smart is recruiting and developing talent, Georgia is positioned as the most formidable program at present and into the future. Meanwhile, Brian Kelly’s LSU Tigers are on the rise.
Plus, NIL and immediate eligibility for transfers offer avenues for other programs to assemble top talent. Those evolutions in the sport make it more difficult for one program, like Alabama, to stockpile talent.
Because of the freedom of player movement, college football appears headed for a future with more year-over-year fluidity among the top 30 or so programs.
No longer will every top prospect want to play for Saban if that prospect believes he can secure a better NIL deal elsewhere.
If Saban coaches another five seasons, I think he’ll win another national title, and Alabama will remain a perennial playoff contender. But if Saban wins one title in the ensuing five seasons, that would mark one championship in a seven-year span, following its 2020 national championship team.
Smart’s Bulldogs are trending toward a dynastic run.
Alabama is trending toward being a perennial contender and an occasional champion.
Blake Toppmeyer is an SEC Columnist for the Paste BN Network. Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com and follow him on Twitter @btoppmeyer.