Aaron Rodgers may have arrived, but Steelers still need to take four more steps
The big domino finally tumbled in Pittsburgh, Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers agreeing to a one-year contract last week that paved the way for the four-time NFL MVP to participate in this week's mandatory minicamp.
But make no bones about it, there’s extensive work yet to be done in the Steel City if the home team wants to make serious inroads toward winning a record seventh Super Bowl rather than simply maintaining its recent standing as a playoff-caliber team that strikes little fear into its postseason competition.
Here are four steps the Steelers ought to strongly consider taking on what they finally hope is their long awaited “Stairway to Seven.”
1. Lock Rodgers and Arthur Smith into a room
It's of paramount importance that Pittsburgh's new QB1 and his offensive coordinator quickly get on the same page. (Obviously.) Based on what Rodgers said Tuesday, it seems like their relationship has had something of a running start.
Yet it’s worth underscoring the point. This isn’t New York, where Rodgers was intimately familiar with OC Nathaniel Hackett and the playbook that awaited when the Jets traded for him two years ago. Rodgers also didn't find several former teammates on hand at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex as a welcoming committee.
Yes, Smith will surely want Rodgers to be comfortable in his new environs, and the quarterback signaled that he expects some of his preferences will be accommodated.
"I'm going to learn the offense, and Arthur and I are going to talk a bunch this summer. If there's things that I like that I'd like to see in the offense, Arthur, I'm sure, is going to put it in," said Rodgers.
"He knows how to call a game. I know how to get us in the right spot based on what's called."
Yet Smith's philosophy also emphasizes establishing the ground game and a heavy reliance on play-action. He fancies having two and even three tight ends on the field, meaning Rodgers, who’s operated a robust passing attack (with the run game often an afterthought) for most of his sterling career, could routinely be executing plays with just one or two targets deployed downfield.
Rodgers is 41. Smith is 43. Both have exceptional offensive minds. They oughta get a six-pack at some point – Smith was known to have a beer with his players after a victory when he was the Atlanta Falcons’ head coach – and/or maybe some of the fine bourbon Rodgers tends to favor and start hashing out a plan that can work for both of them and the Steelers at large. (Obviously.) Maybe they even bunk together when the team relocates to Latrobe, Pa., this summer for training camp.
But after a disastrous 2024 campaign − the worst full season of his 20-year career − Rodgers can hardly afford to be a square peg in a round offensive hole. Conversely, Smith can’t allow himself to be drawn into another dysfunctional relationship – which he had with Russell Wilson last season, according to reports – with his quarterback. And, frankly, running the ball shortens games, keeps the defense fresh and should lighten the burden on Rodgers − which should be a welcome byproduct given his age and all the physical abuse he absorbed last year for a Jets team that threw the ball way too often … and that imbalance was predictive of their 5-12 record.
WINNERS AND LOSERS: Sooo many questions as Rodgers finally heads to Pittsburgh
2. Import another weapon
The Steelers knew what they were doing when they jettisoned WR George Pickens last month – and hard to see a scenario where he would have jelled well with Rodgers anyway. "That would have been a disaster," former New York Giants personnel executive Marc Ross told Paste BN Sports recently.
Still, sure seems like Pittsburgh could use one more bona fide playmaker aside from WR DK Metcalf, who was acquired earlier this offseason, yet is typically a player who works well down the boundary and often relies on his physical prowess to overpower or blow past defensive backs. Last year anyway, Rodgers had become a passer who wanted to distribute the ball quickly and seemed more comfortable working the hashes – which could mean more judicious targeting of Metcalf, whom he's already tried to become acclimated with this spring.
STEALERS? Jets may have the QB Pittsburgh actually needed
Though neither can realistically be classified as a game breaker, TE Pat Freiermuth and slot WR Calvin Austin III could find themselves frequently in Rodgers’ crosshairs, assuming both conform to Rodgers' exacting route standards. WR Roman Wilson might be a field flipper – based on his work at the University of Michigan – but after playing only five snaps in an injury-aborted rookie year, he remains an X-factor.
It’s a long way of saying that since the Steelers have cast their lot with Rodgers in 2025, then they should continue casting a wider net. Maybe that means bringing in an experienced, reliable receiver like Keenan Allen or Amari Cooper, both currently free agents. Maybe it means ramping up talks with the Miami Dolphins to obtain TE Jonnu Smith, a favorite of Arthur Smith’s in Tennessee and Atlanta, as he enters the final year of his contract. Or perhaps GM Omar Khan calls the Jets and inquires about WR Allen Lazard, who’s also got a year remaining on his deal, and considers acquiring a veteran capable of splash plays and offers the benefit of having previously earned Rodgers’ hard-to-gain trust.
But standing pat beyond the Rodgers acquisition in this circumstance just doesn’t cut it.
3. Get Kaleb Johnson ready
A third-round pick this year out of Iowa, Johnson led the Big Ten with 1,537 rushing yards and 23 total touchdowns in 2024. But the presumed replacement for Najee Harris as Pittsburgh’s lead back wasn’t much of a receiver in college. Maybe that won’t be a major hindrance in the NFL given the presence of third-down specialist Jaylen Warren, who’s averaged about 45 catches during his three NFL seasons in Pittsburgh. But if Johnson wants to be on the field in high-leverage situations, then he needs to be ready to catch the ball and, far more importantly, must be prepared to protect Rodgers. Otherwise, he’s going to find himself standing next to Arthur Smith and head coach Mike Tomlin quite often when the stakes are highest.
4. Pay T.J. Watt already
Rodgers is the Steelers' newest player. Watt remains their best. He’s also in need of an extension with one year to go on his existing deal, which now ranks seventh (in terms of average annual salary) among edge rushers − though fat chance you’re going to find six sack artists better than the four-time All-Pro and single-season sack record holder. Aside from being cryptic on social media, Watt hasn’t said much this spring – and, despite skipping minicamp, his situation has largely been overshadowed with the spotlight trained on the Steelers’ pursuit of Rodgers. But it’s time for Pittsburgh to give Watt the raise he deserves given he's averaging $28 million annually while division rival Myles Garrett’s new four-year mega-pact comes in at $160 million.
Good, bad or indifferent, Rodgers is going to bring a level of distraction to this team. The Steelers shouldn’t invite another one, especially as it pertains to rewarding one of the best and most loyal soldiers in franchise history at a time when all the attention is focused on their hired gun.
All NFL news on and off the field. Sign up for Paste BN's 4th and Monday newsletter.